Comparing ERC with Other Tax Credits

A Detailed Breakdown of ERTC and Eligibility For Additional Tax Credits

In the landscape of business tax incentives, the Employee Retention Credit (ERC) stands out as a significant provision born out of the federal government’s response to the COVID-19 crisis. Initially established under the CARES Act, the ERC offers a fully refundable tax credit to employers for wages paid to retained employees during the pandemic. Understanding its substance and practical implications is crucial for businesses aiming to maximize their tax benefits.

Comparing the ERC to other tax credits, such as the Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit and the Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC), reveals distinct eligibility requirements, scopes, and calculation methods. Each credit serves a different purpose: while the ERC aims to encourage employee retention, the R&D Credit incentivizes businesses to invest in innovation, and the WOTC supports hiring from certain groups facing employment barriers. As such, a careful analysis of their differences helps in composing an effective tax strategy that can potentially benefit an organization’s financial health.

Key Takeaways

  • The ERC offers refundable tax credits to aid employers in staff retention during COVID-19.
  • Different credits like the ERC, R&D, and WOTC have unique benefits and eligibility norms.
  • The strategic application of multiple tax credits can enhance an entity‚Äôs financial strategy.

Overview of the Employee Retention Credit (ERC)

The Employee Retention Credit (ERC) originated during the COVID-19 pandemic as a pivotal economic relief measure. Implemented under the CARES Act, the ERC offers a refundable tax credit to businesses, incentivizing them to keep employees on their payroll during periods of significant disruption.

Eligibility Criteria

  • Businesses of any size could qualify, but specific requirements must be met.
  • For the tax years 2020 and 2021, the circumstances include full or partial suspension of business operations due to governmental orders or a significant decline in gross receipts.

Credit Amounts

  • The credit value was up to $5,000 per employee for 2020 and up to $14,000 per employee for 2021.
  • The credit applies against employment taxes, providing direct relief to employers.

Claiming the Credit

  • Employers can claim the ERC on their quarterly tax returns.
  • It was possible to adjust previous quarter filings if the credit wasn’t initially claimed.

In terms of its function within tax policy, the ERC stands out due to its role in responding to an emergent economic crisis and its broader eligibility criteria compared to other credits. It offered substantial support to businesses during uncertain economic times, aiming to mitigate lay-offs and maintain employment levels. Notably, the ERC’s impact and stipulations evolved, adapting to the changing economic landscape created by the pandemic.

Eligibility Criteria for the ERC

To qualify for the Employee Retention Credit (ERC), businesses must meet specific criteria as set by the federal government. Eligibility depends on the calendar quarters in which they are claiming the credit.

For 2020, businesses are eligible if they:

  • Experienced a full or partial suspension of operations due to governmental orders related to COVID-19, or
  • Saw a significant decline in gross receipts for any quarter compared to 2019.

A significant decline for 2020 is defined as a decrease of more than 50% in gross receipts.

For 2021, the thresholds for eligibility were adjusted:

  • The decline in gross receipts threshold was amended to a more than 20% decrease compared to the same quarter in 2019, and/or
  • Were subjected to government-imposed restrictions due to the pandemic.

Additionally, the size of the business affects the determination of qualified wages:

  • Small employers, those with 100 or fewer full-time employees in 2020 and 500 or fewer in 2021, can claim the credit on all wages paid to employees.
  • Larger employers can only claim the credit for wages paid to employees for the time they are not providing services due to the operations suspension or decline in business.

Businesses cannot claim the ERC for the same wages that they have received a Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loan for, but can still claim the ERC on other wages.

Further details on the ERC can be found in the IRS’s official documentation on Employee Retention Credit and Frequently Asked Questions. Eligibility must be carefully documented to comply with IRS requirements as outlined in published guidelines such as Notices 2021-20, 2021-23, and 2021-49, as well as subsequent guidance for audits as discussed by The Tax Adviser.

Calculation of the ERC

The Employee Retention Credit (ERC) involves specific calculations to determine the amount of credit businesses can claim. To calculate the ERC, an eligible employer must:

  1. Confirm Eligibility:
    • They must have operated a business during the calendar year 2020 or 2021.
    • They need to have experienced either a full or partial suspension of their business operations due to orders from a governmental authority limiting commerce, travel, or group meetings due to COVID-19 or
    • They must have experienced a significant decline in gross receipts.
  2. Determine Qualified Wages:
    • Qualified wages are those paid to employees during a time of business suspension or a quarter with a significant decline in gross receipts.
  3. Apply Wage Caps:
    • For 2020, the ERC is based on 50% of qualified wages paid, up to $10,000 per employee, for the entire year.
    • For 2021, the credit is 70% of qualified wages paid, up to $10,000 per employee, for each quarter the employer is eligible.
YearPercentage of WagesWage Cap
202050%$10,000 annually
202170%$10,000 quarterly

Employers must reduce payroll tax deposits they would otherwise make, but should not reduce their required deposits for federal income tax withheld, including both employee and employer share of social security and Medicare taxes.

For detailed steps on ERC calculation, including how to determine if a business experienced a qualifying closure, resources like the QuickBooks ERC Calculator can be consulted. It’s important to note that the ERC is a refundable credit, meaning that if the credit exceeds the employer’s total liability of the portion of Social Security in any calendar quarter, the excess is refunded to the employer.

R&D Tax Credits: Definition and Eligibility

An office setting with a researcher reviewing tax credit criteria while comparing R&D tax credits with other available options

Research and Development (R&D) tax credits are designed to incentivize companies to invest in innovation within the United States. They are applicable to efforts undertaken in creating new products or improving existing products or processes.


R&D tax credits directly reduce the amount of tax owed by businesses that engage in qualifying research activities. These credits are not exclusive to traditional “lab coat” sectors; companies in various industries may qualify.


To be eligible for the R&D tax credits, businesses must meet four basic criteria defined by the Internal Revenue Code and substantiated by the CREDIT Qualification Test:

  1. New or Improved Business Component: The activity must aim for a new or improved function, performance, reliability, or quality in a business component.
  2. Technological in Nature: The process of experimentation must rely on principles of physical or biological science, engineering, or computer science.
  3. Elimination of Uncertainty: Activities must intend to eliminate uncertainty about the capability, method, or design of a product or process.
  4. Process of Experimentation: A process of evaluation must be conducted to resolve the technological uncertainties. This may include systematic trial and error, modeling, or simulation.

Documentation, such as records of experiments, iterations, and results, is essential to support the claim for R&D tax credits. Businesses may claim these credits when they file their income tax returns, utilizing IRS Form 6765.

Note: This is a high-level overview; businesses should consult with a tax professional to understand the complexities of qualifying activities and to gain the full benefit of R&D tax credits.

Comparison of ERC and R&D Tax Credits

The Employee Retention Credit (ERC) and the Research & Development (R&D) Tax Credit serve distinct purposes but can potentially intersect for businesses. The ERC was introduced as a response to the COVID-19 pandemic to aid employers in retaining their workforce, while the R&D Tax Credit is an ongoing incentive for companies engaging in eligible research activities.

  • Eligibility:
    • The ERC applies to salaries paid up to a certain threshold to employees during eligible quarters affected by the pandemic.
    • The R&D Tax Credit benefits companies investing in innovation and research activities that meet specific IRS criteria.
  • Claim Period:
    • Businesses could claim the ERC for wages paid during 2020 and 2021 but must adhere to the timing and ordering rules.
    • The R&D credit is available every year, provided the IRS requirements are met.
  • Benefit Types:
    • The ERC provided a refundable tax credit against certain employment taxes.
    • The R&D Tax Credit allows for a reduction in income taxes or, for qualifying small businesses, against payroll taxes.
  • Interaction:
    • Wages used for the ERC cannot be claimed for the R&D credit.
    • Companies must carefully calculate the R&D credit if they also received the ERC to avoid “double-dipping.”

Companies must evaluate their situation to understand how they can leverage both types of credits without overlap. The IRS provided guidance mandating that the ERC must reduce eligible qualified wages for the research tax credit, as explained in the IRS comparison chart. Furthermore, businesses should consult with tax professionals to optimize their tax credit strategy, taking into account the comprehensive advice found in sources such as this one from Moss Adams.

Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC) Explained

The Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC) is a federal incentive offered to employers who hire individuals from certain groups that have historically faced significant barriers to employment. This credit aims to promote diversity in the workplace and assist American workers in securing gainful employment.

Employers seeking to take advantage of the WOTC can target the hiring of eligible individuals from groups such as veterans, recipients of certain types of public assistance, and those with employment challenges due to physical or mental disabilities.

Eligibility Criteria:

  • Veterans
  • SNAP (food stamp) recipients
  • Disabled individuals enrolled in vocational rehabilitation programs
  • Ex-felons
  • Others facing employment obstacles

The value of the tax credit depends on the number of hours the employee works. It is calculated as 25% of the wages for individuals who work at least 120 hours during their first year of employment and 40% for those working at least 400 hours.

Hours WorkedCredit Percentage
120 – 39925%
400 or more40%

Employers must obtain certification that an individual is a member of a targeted group before they can claim the credit. Claims for the WOTC are made on the federal tax return form, and the specific form and instructions can be found through the Internal Revenue Service.

Employers need to understand that claiming the WOTC does not just provide a financial advantage but also helps to address socioeconomic disparities by offering meaningful employment opportunities to those who might otherwise be overlooked.

Contrasting ERC Benefits with WOTC

When comparing the Employee Retention Credit (ERC) with the Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC), employers should consider the distinct eligibility requirements, claiming procedures, and potential credit amounts offered by each program.

Eligibility Differences

ERC: The program targets employers who retain their employees during periods of economic hardship such as the COVID-19 pandemic. Employers of any size that faced either a full or partial suspension of operations or a significant decline in gross receipts are typically eligible.

WOTC: This credit is designed to encourage the hiring of individuals from certain groups that have consistently faced significant barriers to employment.

Claiming Procedures

ERC: Employers can claim the credit against their payroll taxes by filing their quarterly form 941, and they can also apply for an advance payment of the credit in some instances.

WOTC: Requires employers to obtain certification that the employee is a member of a targeted group before they can claim the credit. This involves filling out IRS Form 8850 by the day the job offer is made and then submitting it to the Department of Labor.

Credit Amount Differences

  • ERC: Offers a credit of up to 70% of qualifying wages paid, up to $10,000 per employee per quarter in 2021. Therefore, the maximum credit an employer could claim per employee is $7,000 per quarter.
  • WOTC: The credit varies depending on the target group the employee belongs to, but it can be as high as $9,600 per eligible employee but this amount is a one-time benefit, not one that compounds quarterly.

Other Business Tax Credits

When considering the landscape of business tax incentives, companies should be aware of two significant credits: the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit and Investment Tax Credits. Each serves a distinct purpose and can offer substantial financial benefits.

Small Business Health Care Tax Credit

Small businesses providing health care benefits to their employees may qualify for the Small Business Health Care Tax Credit. To be eligible, companies must have fewer than 25 full-time equivalent employees, pay average annual wages below a certain threshold, and cover at least 50% of full-time employees’ premium costs.

  • Credit Value: Up to 50% of premium expenses for small business employers, 35% for small tax-exempt employers.
  • Eligible Employers: Those enrolled in a Small Business Health Options Program (SHOP) plan.

Investment Tax Credits

Investment Tax Credits (ITC) encourage companies to invest in certain types of property by reducing their tax liability. The credit amount varies based on the investment type.

  • Eligible Properties: Generally includes solar energy systems, fuel cell properties, and small wind turbines.
  • Credit Value: Can offset up to 30% of the cost of eligible property, though it often phases down over time.

Businesses should consult with a tax professional to understand how these credits could impact their financial strategies.

Combining ERC with Other Tax Credits

Paycheck protection program ppp loan for small business forgiveness application.

When navigating tax incentives, businesses must understand how the Employee Retention Credit (ERC) interacts with other available tax credits. Properly combining the ERC with other incentives can maximize a company’s tax benefit portfolio.

ERC and R&D Tax Credits: One such interaction is between the ERC and the Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credits. Businesses can claim both tax credits for the same period; however, they cannot use the same wages to calculate both credits. A business needs to strategize the allocation of wages to optimize the utilization of both credits effectively.

  • PPP Loans: Originally, businesses that received Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loans were ineligible for the ERC. This was later changed, allowing businesses to claim the ERC even if they had a PPP loan, provided the wages were not also used for seeking PPP loan forgiveness.

Here’s a brief comparison of potential interactions:

Tax CreditInteraction with ERC
R&D Tax CreditsCan claim both but must use different wages for each credit.
PPP LoansCan be combined with ERC if wages are not counted for PPP forgiveness.

Businesses should be aware that there is a precise timeline for claiming these tax credits, particularly if they are considering filing amended payroll tax returns to claim the ERC retroactively. Furthermore, proper documentation and calculations are essential to ensure compliance and optimize tax benefits when combining credits.

Effects of Tax Credits on Business Planning

When businesses integrate tax credits such as the Employee Retention Credit (ERC) into their financial strategies, they can significantly influence business planning. The ERC, introduced under the CARES Act, is a prominent example, as it allowed employers to claim up to 70% of $10,000 in qualifying wages paid per employee per quarter for 2021. Understanding the interplay between the ERC and R&D credits has been critical for companies aiming to optimize their tax positions.

Tax credits can impact business planning in several ways:

  • Cash Flow: Tax credits can improve cash flow in the short term, allowing businesses to reinvest in operations, research, and growth initiatives.
  • Investment Decisions: Companies may be more inclined to pursue R&D projects knowing that a portion of their costs could be offset by tax credits, influencing the scope and direction of their investments.
  • Budgeting: Accurate forecasting and budgeting are enhanced when businesses routinely involve potential tax credits, leading to more efficient use of resources.
  • Risk Management: By leveraging the security that comes with governmental tax incentives, businesses may be better positioned to manage financial risks during uncertain economic periods.

While the specifics of each credit determine its exact effect, the overarching theme is that the strategic use of tax credits aids in the stability and growth of businesses. Thus, companies are encouraged to remain informed about the ever-evolving tax landscape to capitalize on applicable credits and deductions.

Legislative Context of Business Tax Credits

ERTC Tax Credit

In the landscape of U.S. tax legislation, various business tax credits have been implemented to encourage specific economic activities and support businesses during challenging times. Tax credits directly reduce a company’s tax liability, offering more substantial savings than deductions, which only reduce the income subject to tax.

Employee Retention Credit (ERC): Initiated under the CARES Act in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the ERC aimed to incentivize businesses to retain employees during economic hardships caused by the health crisis.

Research and Development (R&D) Tax Credit: A longstanding fixture in the U.S. tax code, the R&D tax credit supports companies investing in innovation and the development of new products and processes.

Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC): This credit promotes the hiring of individuals from certain groups who face significant barriers to employment, providing a financial incentive to employers to create job opportunities for these individuals.

  • Legislative changes: Legislation frequently adjusts the parameters of these credits, either broadening or narrowing their scope. For instance, recent updates from Congress and the IRS have addressed the ERC, indicating its temporal nature and alignment with economic recovery phases.

Each credit carries specific eligibility criteria, definitions of qualified expenditures, and documentation requirements. Companies must navigate complex rules to determine which credits they can claim and how to apply them effectively to their tax situation.

In summary, the U.S. has a dynamically evolving framework of business tax credits, reflecting ongoing legislative actions to address economic conditions and public policy goals. These credits serve as tools for both economic stimulus and strategic business planning.

Frequently Asked Questions

Employee Retention Credit

Understanding the intricacies of various tax credits can be complex. Below are some targeted questions and answers to clarify how the Employee Retention Credit (ERC) compares to other tax credits available to businesses.

How do the Employee Retention Credit (ERC) qualifications differ from other tax credits?

The ERC qualifications focus on businesses that have been financially impacted by COVID-19 and retain their employees. Unlike many other tax credits, the ERC is not restricted to any specific industry or the hiring of certain employee groups.

What are the key differences between the ERC and the Work Opportunity Tax Credit (WOTC)?

While the ERC is designed to incentivize businesses to keep employees on the payroll during COVID-19, the WOTC aims to encourage the hiring of individuals from certain targeted groups that face significant barriers to employment.

How can businesses determine eligibility and calculate their potential ERC compared to other tax credits?

Businesses must assess COVID-19-related impacts on their operations and refer to IRS guidelines to determine ERC eligibility. As for calculating potential credits, the ERC details include specific formulae based on qualified wages, which differ from other tax credit methodologies.

In what ways does the ERC differ from the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) in terms of benefits for businesses?

The ERC provides a direct tax credit to eligible businesses, while the PPP offers potentially forgivable loans to cover payroll and other expenses. Each program has distinct eligibility criteria and benefit structures.

What are the comparison criteria for different quarters when calculating the ERC?

The comparison criteria involve assessing a decline in gross receipts quarter-over-quarter against the same quarter in the previous year. Calculations must adhere to ERC eligibility changes as updated by the IRS.

What is the typical range of the Employee Retention Credit received by eligible businesses?

The typical range of the ERC can vary significantly, with credits initially capped at $5,000 per employee for 2020 and expanded up to $28,000 per employee for 2021. The exact amount depends on various factors detailed in the ERC Comparison Chart.

Scroll to Top